Sunday, April 11, 2010

WTF is up with club funding

When I was an ASUN Senator--my first time around, nearly four years ago--the UNR Rugby club was just starting to become something exceptional. They were gaining national recognition, had managed to get a very good coach and were looking for opportunities to improve their name recognition. They came to ASUN for money to augment their travel fund. Their budget request was heard at the same meeting as a request from the Apple Boppers (a club dedicated to destroying apples in the pursuit of Nirvana or some such BS).

I made the argument that support of a club like the Rugby Club, because of the recognition it could garner for the school, is probably more valuable than support for a club like the Apple Boppers (especially in an environment of scarce resources).

Sandy disagreed. All clubs are created equal. Who are mere senators to create distinctions, she argued. A reasonable ideological distinction to be sure. It was not some form of the philosophy I argued at that meeting that became the dominant one in the execution or drafting of club funding policies over the next few years. It was Sandy's.

I believe this is a fundamental flaw in ASUN. Not all ideas are created equal. Not all pursuits are equally valid. Not all clubs are equally beneficial. A club like the Pack Patriot or UNR-SFL or RHA or AASA does much more for the campus culture and the students directly involved than clubs like the Apple Boppers or Club 1457, but the funding procedures don't recognize that. They don't even hope to attain a level of awareness that would allow intelligently directed "investment" in the campus' future.

This is unfortunate given the high demand for funds in the face of the limited supply. The ASUN should seek to achieve a funding structure that supports campus community, education and development.

Read more...

Friday, April 9, 2010

Don't get no respect...

ASUN Senator Jessica Purney, a two-term representative for the College of Education, called out two-term ASUN President Eli O'Reilly in her status, writing: "Eli Reilly once again has no respect for the legislative body by vetoing an almost unanimous bill from the 77th session because of his opinion."

On one hand it seems like Sen. Purney's rationale completely misses the obvious point that the ASUN Constitution establishes a separation of powers between the legislative and executive branches, and that it is the President's prerogative to veto legislation just as it is the Senate's prerogative to override a veto.

Furthermore, the Senate is by far the more powerful branch of government. Sen. Purney complains that the executive pushed the Senate to pay for mascot uniforms for the athletic department, and that he created high-paying positions on his cabinet. However, those positions were funded by the consent of the Senate, and the Senate can destroy those positions at nearly any time (so long as they are not constitutional offices).

On the other hand, I think it says something about the ASUN advisors that even with two years of experience, ASUN government officials seem to have so many gaps in their institutional knowledge. As an undergrad I probably would pointed the finger at Sen. Purney and impugn her competence for complaining about problems that have constantly been within her domain to address and fix. Having developed a broader view of ASUN, I think it is more appropriate to ask why the faculty advisor to the Senate has not provided more guidance to the legislature to inform them of their legal powers.

Most senators end up serving only one term. That is not enough time for them to learn on their own what power they wield. They must rely on someone else for assistance. If that advisor is indifferent, or worse, calculating, there is a risk that ASUN will be less able to fulfill its mission to serve the needs of all students.

This raises the question… what portion of the ASUN budget goes to feed the salaries of ASUN professional faculty?

Read more...

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

What happens to an office when it is repealed?

Tonight the ASUN Senate will consider a bill to create an ASUN Department of Traditions. Overall, the reorganization of the existing Homecoming Programming Department to include other large events seems to be an interesting idea, although there still isn't a clear reason why there needs to be two programming departments in ASUN.

One thing, though, caught my eye in the bill. It repeals the act establishing the Homecoming Programming Department and the Director of Homecoming Programming without dealing with those who hold office with unexpired terms.

It appears that someone holds the office of director right now. The current officer's term, under the act, expires November 30, 2011. So what happens to this officer should this bill become law?

To me, the critical issue is whether an incumbent has a vested right in continuing to hold office until the natural termination of the term. I really don't know the answer to this question. It seems reasonable to me that the Senate has the unfettered power to abolish the offices it creates, but it also seems reasonable that an officer has some sort of contract right in her appointment to an office.

Thoughts?

Read more...

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

A response to legal questions with Faceboook and ASUN?

Timing seems awfully coincidental.

Ken Munsterman, March 31 at 3:03pm

Hello everyone! Just to give you the heads up, we have created a new ASUN fan page! This new page is your source for everything from your student government, from activities to important reminders. Please join the page as this group will be shut down in two weeks.

http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Associated-Students-of-the-University-of-Nevada-Reno/294825107734
Maybe this is a response to the legal issues I posed here.

Read more...

Saturday, March 27, 2010

What you do speaks so loud that I cannot hear what you say.

It is easy to assume one's cause so virtuous as to justify any action in support of it. The youthful libertarians of UNR Student's for Liberty convinced themselves their recent Abolish ASUN event was a justified attack on a system they find wasteful. Not too many people were amused with the event. Many expressed disgust. However, the political savants at UNR-SFL remain unapologetically unabashed. Those who are annoyed, bemused, confused, disgusted, enraged, flabbergasted, etc are just too simple-minded to get the enlightened point being made by UNR-SFL.

Well, John Russell has proved his assumed beliefs might be just a little too large for him to wear intelligently. His recent post condemning ASUN's Flipside Productions recent event suggests he still does not get why people will label him and his fellow club members hypocrites and still support Flipside's event.

You stand on a soapbox professing disdain for waste and then engage in waste yourself; regardless of the purpose, you are a hypocrite. The club's petty behavior may have made a point, but it was not done elegantly. It was done with contempt and displayed rank hypocrisy.

p.s. Another reason you are all hypocrites is your voluntary attendance at a tax supported state sponsored school.

Be what you would seem to be - or, if you'd like it put more simply - never imagine yourself not to be otherwise than what it might appear to others that what you were or might have been was not otherwise than what you had been would have appeared to them to be otherwise.
~Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland

Read more...

Wasteful spending is wasteful spending

As rare as this occasion is: Agreed.

Now, that's not to say that all entertainment programming is wasteful. Spending on entertaining as part of larger events, such as Homecoming and Mackay Week, is probably more justifiable than just a random event. This spending might also be justified as providing students something to do late at night as an alternative to drinking.

Holding two events with essentially the same activities within a short time period seems duplicative, as well. Duplicative events by their nature are wasteful. To our friends at UNR SFL, I pose this question: Ignoring your premise that ASUN is wasteful because it coercively takes from all to support the "annonyingly active," is all programming spending wasteful? If not, what is not wasteful?

There might also be First Amendment issues implicated by ASUN's practice of banning from their Facebook pages individuals who express dissenting views. Even though government is utilizing a private service (Facebook), the government cannot act in ways that violate a person's constitutional rights. And guess what, ASUN is a government actor. At the very least, ASUN might want to consult with an attorney to determine what its First Amendment liabilities are with respect to its use of Facebook and other social media outlets to connect with ASUN members.

And we're not the only ones to notice this as an issue. The problem with the ASUN's Facebook pages is it appears ASUN and ASUN officers create forums with no announced limits on participation--an open forum--and then engage in editorial control over comments and membership--censorship. This is a no-no and potentially opens ASUN and the University to liability in a civil rights suit.

Read more...

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Senate should abandon laws revision

Given the recent revelations about the cases filed against the Senate and other ASUN officials challenging their legal sufficiency, the Senate might want to wake up and take notice about what is happening.

Just today the Judicial Council informed the parties that it intends to grant summary judgment against ASUN on all remaining cases in light of two ASUN officers admitting liability in the cases.

Sen. Sean Hostmeyer's project to revise and codify all ASUN law is in serious jeopardy given these cases. Practically, the Senate should scrap this project so it can get its bearings in light of the Judicial Council decisions. Much of what ASUN has done during the 76th Senate Session is now invalid, and the application of the precedents could invalidate much of what the 77th Session has done.

The biggest problem at this point is it is entirely unclear what is the law and what is not the law given the decisions against ASUN. Sen. Hostmeyer's project only works if what is being revised and codified is in fact currently law. But under the Open Meeting Law (OML), any action taken in violation of that law is void. The Judicial Council has now ruled that the Senate has engaged in countless OML violations. This is fatal to the revised statutes (now called the revised code) project.

Although in three of the cases the Judicial Council declined to declare the ASUN actions invalid under the OML, ASUN should nonetheless treat them as invalid for a couple of reasons. First, it is the right thing to do. Second, the University and Board of Regents could later step in and invalidate the acts with much more severe consequences. And if some other entity invalidates the underlying acts, the revised statutes would instantly become worthless. There would be no ability to rely on it, defeating its very purpose. The safest thing to do is treat any actions taken as invalid, within the scope of the considered cases, and fix them. Therefore, the senators should scrap the revision proposal, at least until they determine where everything stands. This will take some time.

Most of my previous concerns with the project still apply. I have new concerns about the implementation bill because it creates an inherent conflict in what is the law. The original enactment and the codification? This isn't how codification works. Since ASUN's law and constitution borrows much from the federal system, the Senate would be well advised to borrow the code style the feds use. This would promote consistency and stability, as well as promote the ability for students to learn the styles because many resources are readily available.

Update: For anyone who cares, this is our 200th post. Yay us!

Read more...

BREAKING: Judicial Council rules against Senate, Speaker, President

The ASUN Judicial Council today announced it would issue summary judgment in favor of Corinna Cohn in her remaining cases pending against the ASUN Senate, Speaker of the Senate, ASUN President, and other ASUN officers, including a case to have ASUN's spending during fiscal year 2009 declared illegal.

In the statement filed today, the Council canceled Friday's scheduled hearing on the cases and said that, in light of the admissions of liability from ASUN Senate Speaker Gracie Geremia and ASUN President Eli Reilly, it would issue summary judgment in Cohn's favor. (Disclosure: Cohn is a contributor to this blog.) The Council said it would meet Friday to discuss the summary judgment orders and release them in a timely manner.

Two of the pending cases alleged the ASUN Senate violated the Open Meeting Law (OML) by not keeping and timely producing written minutes of its meetings and violated ASUN law by not properly preparing bills for presidential consideration. The third case challenged the validity of ASUN's budget for fiscal year 2009 on multiple grounds, including several OML violations.

These three cases and three cases decided last month could have far reaching consequences. With respect to the budget, the Council's forthcoming ruling will declare that the ASUN illegally spent around $1.5 million last year. The cases regarding OML violations could have the effect of invalidating much of what the Senate has done in the past couple of years.

The rulings could also open Geremia and other senators to individual liability under the university's code of conduct. Any violation of the OML found under the code of conduct can result in automatic removal from office, as well as other disciplinary sanctions.

Check back later for analysis and commentary.

Read more...

Monday, March 22, 2010

ASUN officers admit liability in cases challenging laws

ASUN President Eli Reilly and Speaker of the Senate Gracie Geremia admitted liability in three cases alleging violations of the Open Meeting Law (OML) and ASUN laws governing enactment of legislation.

In separate statements filed yesterday, respondents Reilly and Geremia admitted that laws, processes, and safeguards were not followed in the Senate consideration and enactment of several bills. Shortly after the filings, the petitioner in the cases, Corinna Cohn, requested the Council issue summary judgment in her favor since nothing at issue was in dispute. (Disclosure: Cohn is a contributor to this blog.)

In his statement in the case to invalidate the fiscal year 2009 budget, Reilly said, "I will admit that process was not entirely followed surrounding the signing into law of the Association budget for fiscal year 2009." Reilly further pleads that none of the omissions were done "in a malicious or intentional manner."

Regarding the case challenging the Senate's failure to timely produce written minutes of its meetings, Geremia blames noncompliance on poor advisement, the fact that student government officials and employees receive no formal training on the law's requirements, and have a high turnover rate from session to session. Geremia also claims that the 75th Session committed similar violations, but that is not before the Council. Geremia concludes that the problems will cease with proper training and advisement.

In the case challenging the proper preparation of legislative measures after Senate passage, Geremia writes, "I recognize that the process was not carried out in the correct manner.... There are many reasons to (sic) why this process wasn’t followed, ranging from a transition in Senate advisement to the resignation of the Secretary of the Senate." Geremia similarly concludes that improved communication will ensure mistakes like this do not occur in the future.

Geremia's statements tended to point the blame at others, particularly ASUN administrative faculty, while Reilly's statements accepted responsibility but claimed the liability was of no consequence since it wasn't done with malicious intent.

None of the statements explicitly indicates the Senate or executive branch should escape the consequences of liability, but all intimate that the Council should overlook the violations of the law.

The statements are in response to three cases still pending from more than a year ago. In February, the Council ruled against ASUN in three other cases alleging various violations of the OML, but refused to invalidate the underlying Senate actions (VLEG coverage here).

To date, the Senate has taken no action in response to these cases. No item has listed these cases on a Senate agenda, and presumably no formal discussion has taken place at Senate meetings regarding these cases. It does not appear Geremia issued her statements admitting liability with the consent of the Senate, possibly exceeding her authority as speaker. The Senate is named as a respondent in the cases and the Senate never delegated authority to the speaker to answer the cases.

Geremia's admissions of OML liability also open her to university disciplinary sanctions under the NSHE Code. The punishment for being found liable for OML violations is removal from office and other possible sanctions under the code of conduct, including disciplinary notation on the violator's transcript.

All six cases, if ruled in Cohn's favor, will create binding precedents that will invalidate much of the 76th Senate Session's actions, and could have application to the acts of the current Senate session as well.

The three cases pending are scheduled for argument on March 26. With the admissions of liability, it is possible the Council will cancel argument and issue summary judgment.

The cases pending are numbered AN-003, AN-005, and AN-006 (available here).

Read more...

Friday, March 19, 2010

Still pending, three years later

Another ASUN Election has passed, and a constitutional amendment ratified by the students an eternity ago (three years) is still pending. This has been well discussed in this space before. Since the previous posts have been getting some traffic lately, perhaps someone has noticed this somewhat important oversight.

Previous posts:
What Constitutional Amendment?
Oh, That Constititonal Amendment
Another BoR meeting, constitutional amendment still pending

Since the amendment was ratified back in 2008, the Regents have enacted a policy delegating the approval power over student government constitutions to the Chancellor. See section 1.3.6 of Chapter 1, Title 2, Board of Regents Handbook. Thus, the Regents do not have to approve the amendment, but the amendment still must be formally transmitted to the university president, and ASUN law is explicit about whose duty that is.

Once again, in hopes of making this all so utterly easy a caveman could do it, below is a specimen certificate, updated for current Election Commission Chairman Jeremiah Todd. All he needs to do--literally--is print out the certificate the number of times required under ASUN law, sign them, and send to them to the required recipients.

I have to say, I'm hard pressed to think of anything more embarassing to anyone ever involved in ASUN, the administrative faculty included, than letting the people's votes go ignored, particularly on something so important.

Specimen Certificate to UNR President on ASUN Constitutional Amendment_rev 2010-03-19

Please, someone, anyone, fix this so I can stop writing about it.

Read more...

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Congratulations to the President and Vice President elect and the Members of the 78th ASUN Senate

As promised, some brief analysis.
  • Jose won by an 8-point margin
  • Sadykova won by a 14-point margin
  • All 5 incumbent senators won reelection. The only ASUN insider to lose was Shirley Diaz, although it was inevitable for an insider to lose in that race.
  • 14 men and 8 women were elected to the Senate
  • About 12 percent of the undergraduate student body voted, about the same as in the past few years
  • Both advisory funding questions passed by more than 60 percent of the vote
  • The closest race, in the School of Journalism, was decided by three votes
Once we have the numbers, we will compare voter turnout rates by college.

The most surprising result from this election was student support for increased fees. By significant margins, both questions passed. It is evidence that even in times of increased tuition and fees, students are willing to pay additional fees for specific programs and services.

Also of note is how smoothly this election was conducted. Major kudos to Commission Chair Jeremiah Todd and his entire crew. Their hard work is apparent and they deserve our praise. Great job, guys!

2010 ASUN General Election Uncertified Results

Winners in bold; NOTA stands for none of the above. Some analysis later.

President of the Associated Students
Charlie Jose-850
Casey Stiteler-713

Vice President of the Associated Students
Shirley Diaz-657
Leissan Sadykova-855

Senator for the College of Agriculture, Biotechnology, and Natural Resources (2 seats)
Jeffrey Fine-49
Corey Jokerst-78
Randy Pares-38
Chelsea Truax-61
NOTA-0

Senator for the College of Business Administration (3 Seats)
Jake Butera-151
Richard Corn-117
Jacob Crawley-91
Mathew Neben (Incumbent)-157
NOTA-20

Senator for the College of Education (2 seats)
Ashlee Benton-35
Jourdan Douglas-17
Edna Meza-43
David Ronan-48

Senator for the College of Engineering (2 Seats)
Alexandria Hill-70
Adam Khan-70
Roger Przybyla-53
NOTA-16

Senator for the College of Liberal Arts (8 Seats)
Joseph Barrett-124
Brandon Bishop (Incumbent)-231
Mitch Bottoset (Incumbent)-162
Samuel Crampton-144
Christopher Day-164
Branden Jung-167
Tatiana Kosyrkina-113
Lea Moser (Incumbent)-187
Ann Newsome (Incumbent)-164
Joey Nizuk-123
Jesus Palma-242
Jordan Weaver-119
NOTA-58

Senator for the College of Science (2 Seats)
Joseph Agor-38
Angel Arias-33
Jennifer Masters-54
Natasha Monga-87
Lauren Riley-74
NOTA-0

Senator for the Division of Health Sciences (2 Seats)
John Haller-51
Reynaldo Veloz-67
Kim Williams-70

Senator for the School of Journalism
Jonathan Moore-61
Misha Ray-59

Ballot Question 1- JV $5 Art Fee
Yes-865
No-506

Ballot Question 2- JV $25 Student Support Services Fee
Yes-855
No-534

Read more...

Flashback to 2006

Taking no opinion on the votes expressed here, notice anything amiss?


Bragging rights go to the first person to answer what is wrong and cite to some authority.

Read more...

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Just what exactly do they hope to accomplish?

The UNR Students for Liberty Ludicrousness want to Abolish ASUN. So what exactly do they hope to accomplish? Oh, right. Abolish ASUN. Unfortunately, their latest endeavor in ludicrousness is destined to fail. Putting aside their pure hypocrisy, why are their efforts wasted? Because what they want can't happen.

What exactly is their petition seeking? A student ballot question to dissolve ASUN? Board of Regents action to eliminate ASUN? The petition is unclear as to its effect. Without the petition's legal effect being clear, it is insufficient to be recognized. Aside from the petition's lack of clarity, other concerns exist.

First, as a matter of ASUN law, the petition does not propose a proper popular initiative. The ASUN Constitution limits popular initiatives by petition to constitutional amendments and popular enactment and repeal of legislative acts (i.e. laws subordinate to the constitution). There is nothing in the ASUN Constitution that authorizes the dissolution of the Association (compare student government constitutions that contain express dissolution provisions). As a matter of ASUN law, the petition seeks something that the government cannot grant: a popular vote on whether to abolish ASUN. (This is predicated on my understanding of what the petition in fact seeks.)

Second, the petition is directed to the Board of Regents, suggesting that the petition is not intended to implicate ASUN's electoral process at all (can you understand my confusion about what this petition is asking for?). The Regents are not inclined to abolish ASUN without the consent of the students. But if ASUN cannot legally place a dissolution question on the ballot, this question will never get to the Regents. The only way I see the Regents abolishing ASUN is if the organization becomes so demonstrably corrupt that wiping the slate clean is the only option.

Third, even assuming that ASUN could place a dissolution question on the ballot, what vote would be sufficient to abolish ASUN? A majority of those voting? A majority of the membership of ASUN? It is entirely unclear what vote is necessary, as a matter of law, to dissolve a student government. To me, it seems that an absolute majority of the membership is required. Also, keep in mind that ASUN is not self-chartering. The Board of Regents is the chartering authority. Thus, to eliminate ASUN requires their approval, and as I've said, it's unlikely they'll grant it.

Fourth, the electronic version is an unacceptable medium in which to circulate the petition. ASUN law does not allow for petitions to be circulated electronically. Thus, the ASUN Attorney General has no authority to accept such a petition.

Finally, what the petition is against, namely "a student government that funds itself through a compulsory student fee," implicates a solution that is worse than what exists now. Implicitly, UNR SFL is in favor of an ASUN that does not obtain revenue through a mandatory fee. But it's that mandatory fee that prevents ASUN from engaging in content and viewpoint discrimination when deciding who gets funding and who does not. In other words, if UNR SFL requested funds for its "Abolish ASUN" event under a voluntary fee system, ASUN could deny the request simply because it didn't agree with the message. It is because ASUN has a mandatory fee that the U.S. Constitution prevents ASUN from engaging in viewpoint discrimination.

One last thing to consider: Getting rid of ASUN isn't going to make college less expensive by $5 per credit. The Regents will happily reallocate that money to something else. In short, doing away with ASUN will do more harm to students than good because the students will lose their official representation.

Read more...

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Sweet, sweet video evidence

At the risk of giving Mitch Bottoset and Chris Day attention they do not deserve, we give you this YouTube video.



Pay particular attention at the 2:30 mark in the video. A couple of thoughts.

The Code of Elections makes it a violation to "[use] ASUN authority, facilities, funds, or resources for campaign purposes." Section 14(b)(5). A plain reading of that statute seems to indicate that filming campaign videos in ASUN offices is prohibited.
 
Bottoset and Day (probably for show, given this is intended to be a funny campaign video) appear to pick the lock to ASUN Vice President Charlie Jose's office. Ignoring whether they actually picked the lock, were they authorized to enter that office? If yes, then the only issue is the issue above. If no, is this trespassing or gaining unauthorized entry to an office, in violation of the System Code and state criminal law?

Update: As I initially suspected, the candidates state they were authorized to be in the office. As to my first question, they indicate that even the Election Commission is unclear about how the statute should be applied. Personally, I am torn as to whether this particular instance should be prohibited, never mind if it actually is. In any event, it's clear that this particular statute needs some tweaking to cure its vagueness.

Read more...

A sure way to lose a debate and a giant in the room

A great way to lose a debate: agree with your opponent(s). That is all Jacob Camp, candidate for ASUN President, did in last week's debate. I'm pleased to see the Nevada Sagebrush picked up on this, which was, to several observers of the debate, a giant gorilla in the room. So kudos to the Sagebrush for paying attention to and reporting on the details that mattered. I don't think it's a stretch to say, as far as ASUN coverage is concerned, this is so far the best issue under Editor-in-Chief Jessica Fryman.

That said, there was another giant in the room during the "debate," (available online here--apologies for poor audio) and it wasn't Eli Reilly's epic ego or Casey Stiteler's sense of entitlement, not even Jacob Camp's love fest (but no homo!). It was how painfully obvious how woefully unfamiliar the candidates are--even insiders!--with what ASUN is.

You want to know what ASUN is? An excellent--nay, the only--place to start is with the charter document, the ASUN Constitution, included below for your reading pleasure. For, in the words of "West Wing" character Toby Ziegler, referring to the U.S. Constitution, "in all it is the owner's manual and we should read what it has to say!"

Constitution of the Associated Students of the University of Nevada, 2007

What should we take away from that reading? A few things.
  1. ASUN is an association composed of every undergraduate student at Nevada.
  2. The purpose of the undergraduate student body in establishing ASUN under this constitution is, according to the Preamble, to "advance our interests, set forth our duties, and provide for meaningful participation in the governance of our University." Basically, look after the interests of all undergrads.
  3. The association is governed by a tripartite representative government, and it looks a hell of a lot like the federal government. Although true, this is a government composed of students (i.e. "student government"), it is a government nonetheless.
  4. ASUN is governed under a rule of law.
Now that you've read the ASUN Constitution, we have a framework within which to review the debate. The most evident conclusion is that no candidate is familiar with the owner's manual, the ASUN Constitution. Even Jacob Camp, who claimed superiority over his opponents because he had a copy with him, botched a most basic issue about which offices are created in the constitution. His response after the debate was, "oops."

Particularly with the vice presidential candidates, each has a notion of what the vice president should be, not what it is under the constitution. For those who are curious, the vice president's only constitutional obligations are to be able to succeed to the presidency if need be, to preside over the Senate during judicial impeachments, and do what the Senate or President delegate. That's it. All the jockeying of who is better for diversity was pointless.

I know this next point is nitpicky, but precision with language matters.
  • Legislator, n., a member of a legislature
  • Legislature, n., a body composed of legislators
  • Legislation, n., a written document legislators debate in a legislature
The terms are never interchangeable. Get these right or you'll lose life points.

Last point, universal among the candidates is the idealism to "do good," to "do the right thing," or to help make the campus better. Those are all laudable motivations, but that isn't your job. Getting elected to ASUN means getting elected to run, manage, and lead a government. It is a job with public weight. It means legal duties and obligations, and legal consequences if mistakes are made.

Too often students believe that ASUN is a popular place to be, a resume builder (the perpetual favorite), and really not that serious a thing. But ASUN is more than that. It is a proving ground for future elected leaders. It is a place to learn about functions of government, how governments work. It isn't a sandbox on some playground. So candidates, stop treating it like it is. You'll earn much more credibility if you do.

Read more...

Monday, March 1, 2010

A little presumptuous?

Maybe it's just me, but it seems just a little bit presumptuous to start inviting people to the presidential debate you will hope to appear in before you've even won a spot in the general election.

Read more...

Monday, February 22, 2010

"The President shall give to the Senate information of the state of the Association"

The ASUN Constitution requires the President to "give to the Senate information of the state of the Association, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he or she shall judge necessary and expedient." ASUN Const. art. III, sec. 2(d). This language, borrowed directly from article II, section 3 of the U.S. Constitution, basically means the ASUN President must give a State of the Association address, if we can assume an intent to mirror the practices (I was there, and we can).

Although this provision did not exist under the previous ASUN Constitution, in 2006 the Senate invited ASUN President Jeff Champagne to deliver his annual address before the Senate. 74 ASUN Stat. 11. The invitation was issued under a Senate statute that required the president to deliver an annual address in the fall semester. ASUN Senate Statutes, section 350.1 (April 11, 2007). Since the Senate acts and communicates through the legislation it passes, the invite was a formal resolution.

Since then, the practice envisioned under the current constitution is dramatically lost. During the 75th Session, rather than coordinate a date with the Senate so the address could be attended formally, as it was during the 74th Session, ASUN President Sarah Ragsdale decided to go it alone: she scheduled the event on her own, sent out her own invitations, and never consulted the Senate until after invites were sent out.

The Senate attempted to salvage the event by formally inviting the President to deliver her address before the Senate, as constitutionally required, but the resolution was not agreed to. The Senate felt it had been snubbed (rightfully so, given that the address is to be given to the Senate), and the result was the Senate largely boycotted the speech.

ASUN President Eli Reilly never did deliver a message to the Senate during the 76th Session.

This year, President Reilly is borrowing from Ragsdale. He appears to be going it alone. Why President Reilly is continuing this poor practice is unclear, but it might have something to do with the lack of a professional interbranch relationship between Reilly and Speaker Gracie Geremia.

It is not an accident that we used the language from the Federal Constitution in the ASUN Constitution's rewrite, now all of three years old. We intended the practice to mirror the Congress and the President's State of the Union message. I'd suggest the Senate fix this misunderstanding, take the upper hand, invite the President, and get the practice back in order, but we all know how well the Senate follows procedure and the intended practice set by those who preceded them.

Read more...

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Three strikes against Senate in Council rulings

In three unanimous decisions released yesterday, the ASUN Judicial Council ruled against the ASUN Senate for various violations of the Nevada Open Meeting Law (OML) and ASUN laws implementing the OML.

About a year after initially being filed, the decisions in these cases represent a victory for the petitioner, Corinna Cohn.

In the three cases, the Council found the Senate violated the OML several ways: (1) including an incorrect date on an agenda for a meeting that was held, (2) not satisfying the "clear and complete" agenda requirement, and (3) publishing minutes that do not reflect the substance of what was proposed, discussed, or decided at a meeting.

In none of the cases did the Council decide to invalidate the actions taken in violation of the OML, citing the desire to issue warnings first. But the Council noted it is within its constitutional and statutory power to invalidate actions should similar cases arise in the future.

It is unclear whether the Council exceeded its authority in declining to invalidate the actions, given the plain language of NRS 241.036, which states that any action taken in violation of any provision of the OML is void.

In the case regarding meeting minutes, the Council had especially harsh words for the Senate. "Minutes not recorded with careful and required detail of all actions occurring during the meeting of the Senate is in no way acceptable and is deemed intolerable by requirements of ASUN Law," the Council said in its written decision.

Although these cases have no teeth in and of themselves, they could serve as valuable precedents to invalidate other actions of the Senate, as similar deficiencies have been noted in Senate practice the last two sessions.

These cases were ruled on summary judgment, meaning that the Council found that the petitioner made her case and that the Senate could present no reasonable defense. Some believe that this bodes well for future petitioners who wish to challenge Senate actions based on OML violations.

These cases also could serve as a foundation for seeking individual officer liability under the University code of conduct. ASUN officers who violate the OML are liable to disciplinary action for violating a stated NSHE policy. Such discipline can extend to removal from office and a disciplinary note being placed on a violator's transcript.

Still remaining to be argued are three more cases. One challenges whether the secretary of the Senate can certify to the accurate enrollment and passage of bills purportedly passed before her appointment. The second seeks to invalidate actions taken at meetings where no minutes were published. The third seeks to invalidate the fiscal year 2009 budget. Although that fiscal year has passed, any ruling on that case could set precedents for what is acceptable budgetary practice. The third case also contains several OML violation allegations.

The cases are numbered AN-001 through AN-006. All six cases, evidence, and the rulings are available here.

Read more...

BREAKING: Judicial Council rules against Senate

According to official records, the ASUN Judicial Council yesterday ruled on three of six complaints against the ASUN Senate for various violations of the Nevada Open Meeting Law. Details to come.

Read more...

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Diversity: The Paradox of Paradox

ASUN has a diversity commission that has the supposed goal of helping to push individuals understanding of identity beyond traditional defining characteristics. We should not see black, brown or white. Male and female, there is no difference. Gay, straight, bi, trans-gender, etc does not matter.

There are a few things that are hard to articulate surrounding this particular topic. Sean's attempt at levity and irony attempted to hit on this. There are nearly 40 comments--some not very civil, others noteworthy--on the post, most of which demonstrate a lack of rhetorical skill. Being a vainglorious bastard, I hope to provide some tools here to help some of the people talking about this. I also hope that this might move the discussion, if it continues here, in a more civil direction.

It seems to me, in my very humble and often humbled opinion, that we must recognize the extant notion of diversity to move beyond using it to define people. We cannot flip a switch and divest the world of bigotry, racism, hatred, sexism, ageism, zealotry etc. These are cultural patterns that are in some cases millennium old. They are ingrained in the cultural psyche (gasp, how dare I), embedded in History. This is the unfortunate ambiguity facing the Diversity Commission.

There is also the notion of identity with which to contend. Starting with the premise that individuals are in fact unique presents a problem in attempting to define someone's identity. In the West (gasp again) at least, there is I think a prevalent notion that the individual has a unique identity. And in fact that identity is a natural right. In the simplistic bifurcation of society into state and individual, the state has not the right to demand conformance to social norms (unless the norms protect other individuals from harm) and most not attempt to subsume the individual.

But if we demand an identity, must we not have means to define that identity? Undoubtedly, a concept such as race fails utterly in capturing essential characteristics of an individual. However, other things like religion, geographic location and nationality do often capture parts of a persons identity. And this line of reasoning leads to the trap of accepting these ideas, but we must not accept them, because by accepting them we acknowledge their legitimacy, and we started off not wanting to recognize that they have a legitimate role in defining the individual.

It is here that reality strikes a blow.

Barry Belmont, who I believe confesses to the egregious sin of being a Libertarian, wrote the following in a post belittling Speaker Geremia's apparent non-stance stance (which, unlike Belmont, I think had some valid criticism on contributor Sean's puerile post),

Put yourself [in a blind [wo]mans place] for a day, Gracie. Try to feel how much better the world is when you stop trying to categorize others and realize we’re all just hurtling around this big ol’ universe on a tiny rock. We’re not men, we’re not women, we’re not white nor black nor brown, we’re not Jews, Buddhists, Muslims, we’re not vegetarians and meat-eaters, not gay or straight, not the differences that divide us. We’re just people.

We’re 99+% of the same genetic stuff. It’s time we start acting that way.


I'm honestly a little surprised by that stance, but delving into why would be too many words tangent to my point. To the point, Belmont is from what I have perceived a man of ideas. He has, although I am only acquainted with his writings on SFL, impressed me with his knowledge, logic and rhetoric. I know him solely for his ideas. And he has claimed it is the merit of a person's ideas that is what is worth recognition. However, it is in these ideas themselves that we cannot easily or simply escape from religion or race or sex, because it is these ideas that define, at least in part, identity.

I hold very strongly my belief in the sovereignty of the individual. And I also unequivocally believe my feelings on this have been very heavily shaped by my socioeconomic status and my opinions on religion. These nebulous ideas do play a role in helping us use language to capture the essences of identity. They may be flawed, and each of us has a unique definition for them, but they nonetheless do help create an ultimately imperfect definition of who we are.

And it is for this reason, I see legitimacy for something like the Diversity Commission to exist. However, I have not seen anything from the Diversity Commission that attempts to engage students in this dialogue.

Read more...